How Much Can Car Insurance Increase After an Accident in Florida?

Your Florida premium can rise after a crash if your insurer has good-faith information that you were substantially at fault. State law generally bars a surcharge on liability, PIP, medical payments, or collision coverage when you were not.

Asking how much car insurance goes up after an accident usually comes down to one question: does your insurer believe you caused it? A driver found substantially at fault in a crash with injuries can see a significant surcharge at renewal, while a driver who was rear-ended at a red light often sees no increase at all.

There is no single percentage that applies to every Florida driver, because each carrier sets its own rating plan within the limits of state law.

What Florida does control is when an insurer may add a surcharge in the first place, and that protection is stronger than most drivers realize. If a crash also left you with injuries or an unresolved claim, a Florida car accident attorney can review your options in a free consultation.

Key Takeaways About Car Insurance Increases After an Accident

Here are the points that matter most when you are bracing for a renewal notice.

  • Florida law prohibits surcharging liability, PIP, medical payments, or collision coverage solely because of an accident unless the insurer determines in good faith that the insured was substantially at fault.
  • A driver who was wrongly surcharged can ask to be reimbursed by showing one of several not-at-fault conditions listed in the statute.
  • The size of an at-fault increase depends on the claim amount, whether anyone was hurt, the driver’s prior record, and the carrier’s own rating plan.
  • A PIP claim reflects Florida’s no-fault system and is not, by itself, evidence that the driver caused the crash.
  • Insurers set their own look-back periods, so the length of a surcharge varies from one company to the next.

The sections below explain each of these rules and what you can do if your premium jumps anyway.

How Much Does Car Insurance Go Up After an Accident in Florida?

Car insurance in Florida goes up after an accident by whatever surcharge your carrier’s rating plan assigns to that kind of claim, and that amount differs widely from one company to the next. The increase usually shows up at your next renewal rather than on your current bill.

An accident surcharge typically appears on the renewal offer that follows the claim. That timing gives you a window to dispute the fault finding or shop for new coverage before the higher rate takes effect.

Average-increase figures published online blend drivers from every state, every carrier, and every claim size, so they rarely predict what a specific Florida policy will do. A more useful approach is to look at what your own insurer weighs, starting with whether it has grounds to call you substantially at fault.

Florida premiums can also climb at renewal for reasons unrelated to your crash, such as statewide rate changes or a new vehicle or address. Asking the insurer to separate any accident surcharge from a general rate change shows you which part, if any, you can challenge.

Will My Insurance Go Up If the Accident Was Not My Fault?

Insurance generally should not go up in Florida if you were not at fault, because state law ties accident surcharges to fault. Under Florida’s unfair insurance practices law, an insurer may not add a premium for liability, PIP, medical payments, or collision coverage solely because you were in a crash unless its file contains information showing you were substantially at fault.

When a carrier does add a surcharge or refuses to renew, it must tell you that you may be reimbursed or renewed if you can show that you were:

  • Lawfully parked when the crash happened
  • Reimbursed by the responsible driver, or holding a judgment against that driver
  • Struck in the rear by a vehicle traveling the same direction, without being convicted of a moving violation
  • Hit by a hit-and-run driver, with the crash reported to authorities within 24 hours of discovery
  • Not convicted of a moving violation in the crash while the other driver was convicted of one
  • Found not liable by a court
  • Issued a citation that was later dismissed or dropped
  • Able to provide a written statement of facts showing you were not at fault, which the insurer’s file does not rebut

That last option is broader than many drivers expect, so a surcharge notice is worth answering in writing rather than simply paying.

Insurance officer writing a claim report on clipboard during a car crash insurance process with a man and an insurance agent.

What Factors Affect How Much Car Insurance Increases?

When an insurer finds you substantially at fault, the size of the increase depends on its rating plan, which weighs several details of the crash and your history. The table below shows how the most common factors tend to push a premium.

Factor How It May Affect Your Premium
Fault determination A finding that you were substantially at fault can permit an accident surcharge under Florida law.
Claim amount Larger claims may lead to higher increases, depending on the insurer’s rating plan.
Injuries involved Crashes involving injuries may be rated differently from property-damage-only accidents.
Prior driving and claims history Previous accidents or violations may affect how the insurer evaluates the new claim.
Insurance carrier Each carrier uses its own rating plan, so the same crash may produce different increases.
Ranked By Best Lawyers - Best Law Firms 2026 badge

Because the carrier factor is so large, two Gainesville drivers who were in the same crash can see very different renewal numbers, which is why comparison shopping matters more after an accident than before.

Does Filing a PIP Claim Raise Car Insurance Rates?

A personal injury protection (PIP) claim is part of Florida’s no-fault system, so filing one does not mean you admitted to causing the crash. A liability claim, by contrast, means someone is asking your insurer to pay for harm you allegedly caused.

How PIP Claims Work in Florida

Every Florida driver turns to their own PIP coverage first for medical bills and lost income, regardless of who caused the collision.

Under the PIP statute, benefits pay 80 percent of reasonable medical expenses and 60 percent of lost income, but only if you receive initial care within 14 days of the crash. The full $10,000 is available only when a qualified provider finds an emergency medical condition; otherwise, medical benefits are capped at $2,500.

How Liability Claims Affect Your Premium

A liability claim arises when the other driver, or their insurer, seeks payment from your policy for vehicle damage or injuries. Those claims are the ones most closely tied to fault findings, and they are where a surcharge is most likely to follow.

How Long Does an Accident Stay on Your Record in Florida?

An accident can follow you on two separate records in Florida: your driver license record with the state and your claims history with insurers. Each one runs on its own clock and its own rules.

Florida’s Driver License Point System

The Department of Highway Safety and Motor Vehicles adds points only when you are convicted of a moving violation, not simply because you were in a crash. Under Florida’s point system, a moving violation that results in a crash generally carries 4 points, and 6 points when it involves unlawful speed or unlawful use of a wireless device. Collecting 12 points within 12 months triggers a suspension.

How Long Insurers Consider Accident History

Insurers decide for themselves how many years of accident history to rate, and they spell that out in plans filed with the Florida Office of Insurance Regulation. Asking your agent directly how long a specific surcharge will remain on your policy is the most reliable way to find out.

How to Lower Car Insurance Costs After an Accident

Even after an at-fault crash, Florida drivers have several ways to soften the financial hit. Many people find these steps worthwhile:

  1. Request the surcharge explanation in writing and respond with any not-at-fault evidence you have.
  2. Get quotes from several carriers, since each one weighs a crash differently.
  3. Ask whether your policy includes accident forgiveness, or whether a new carrier offers it.
  4. Elect a basic driver improvement course for an eligible traffic citation, which withholds adjudication and keeps points off your license.
  5. Consider a higher deductible to offset a premium increase, if you can afford the out-of-pocket risk.
  6. Think carefully before filing a small collision claim yourself, weighing the payout against a possible surcharge.

One caution on that last step: skipping a claim does not change your duty to report a qualifying crash to police or to give your insurer the notice your policy requires.

What Else Should You Check After a Florida Car Accident?

Drivers who search for rate information right after a crash often have a bigger issue beneath the surface, such as medical bills, a damaged car, or an adjuster pushing for a quick statement. A premium increase is frustrating, but an unresolved injury claim usually carries far higher stakes.

Before focusing on the renewal, it helps to confirm a few things about the claim itself:

Multi-Million Dollar Advocates Forum Badge | Bagen Law Accident Injury Lawyers
  • Whether you received initial medical care within 14 days, which controls access to PIP benefits
  • Which company insures the other driver, and whether a claim number has been opened
  • Whether a law enforcement crash report exists and what it says about fault
  • Whether any adjuster has asked for a recorded statement or a signed medical authorization

Answers to those questions often shape both your injury recovery and how your own insurer views the crash.

When the at-fault driver carried no bodily injury coverage, your own policy may be the main source of recovery beyond PIP. Claims against your own uninsured motorist coverage follow different rules than claims against another driver’s insurer, and the details of your policy matter.

 

Frequently Asked Questions About Florida Car Insurance Increases

These follow-up questions often come up once Florida drivers start reviewing their renewal paperwork.

Can my insurer refuse to renew after one at-fault accident?

Florida law prohibits an insurer from refusing to renew an auto policy solely because the insured had one at-fault accident within the current three-year period. A second at-fault accident in that window, or other policy violations, can change that answer.

Can a single traffic ticket raise my car insurance rate?

Florida limits surcharges for noncriminal traffic infractions. An insurer generally may not surcharge or refuse to renew based on one such infraction unless it is a second within 18 months, a third within 36 months, or a speeding violation of more than 15 mph over the limit.

Can a driver improvement course prevent an insurance surcharge?

A traffic infraction in Florida where adjudication was withheld and no points were assessed cannot be used to surcharge, cancel, or refuse to renew your auto policy. That protection is one reason electing a driver improvement course can be worth the time.

Does a crash affect uninsured motorist or comprehensive coverage?

Florida law prohibits an insurer from adding a premium for uninsured motorist or comprehensive coverage solely because the insured was in a crash or convicted of a moving violation. Other coverages on the same policy remain subject to the substantially-at-fault rule.

Must I report an accident if I do not file an insurance claim?

Most auto policies require prompt notice of any accident, whether or not you plan to file a claim. Late notice can give the insurer grounds to contest coverage if the other driver later brings a claim against you.

Do Florida drivers age 55 and older qualify for insurance discounts?

Florida requires insurers to give a premium reduction on liability, PIP, and collision coverage to principal operators 55 or older who complete a state-approved accident prevention course. The discount lasts three years, and an insurer may require the driver to stay free of at-fault crashes to keep it.

Talk With Our Gainesville Car Accident Team

Steven A. Bagen
Steven A. Bagen, Personal Injury Lawyer

A renewal notice usually arrives months after a crash, long after the decisions that shape your injury claim have already been made. Getting clear answers early can protect both your finances and your recovery.

At Bagen Law Accident Injury Lawyers, we help drivers in Gainesville and across North Central Florida sort out what the other driver’s insurer owes them and what their own policy covers. Our car accident team and broader Gainesville injury practice are available 24/7. Call 800-800-2575 for a free consultation.